by Steve Warren November 30, 2025
In the shadow of a city grappling with rising street crime and a police force stretched thin, a fresh federal complaint has zeroed in on the Chicago Police Department’s recruitment playbook. Filed last week by America First Legal, the document accuses the city and the CPD of weaving race directly into hiring, promotions, and even day-to-day enforcement—a setup that allegedly spits in the face of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
The complaint lays bare how Chicago’s bureaucrats have baked “equity” mandates into every corner of government operations, from the mayor’s office down to the beat cop. At the heart of it sits the Office of Equity and Racial Justice, a post-2020 creation that’s been churning out racial action plans for agencies like the CPD. These “guidelines” offer explicit directives to prioritize skin color in who gets a badge, who climbs the ranks, and how resources get doled out.
“Chicago is disguising its discriminatory actions under the pretext of ‘racial equity,’ openly defying federal civil rights laws and Executive Orders issued by President Donald J. Trump,” AFL counsel Alice Kass said in the filing.
This is the product of a consent decree hammered out in 2019 between the city, the CPD, and the U.S. Department of Justice—a sprawling 500-plus-page blueprint born from the Laquan McDonald scandal and meant to overhaul policing after findings of routine constitutional violations against Black and Latino residents.
Fast-forward to today, and that decree has ballooned to 714 paragraphs, with extensions pushing full compliance out to at least 2027. The Independent Monitoring Team’s latest report, released October 15, 2025, shows the CPD scraping by with preliminary or partial compliance in most areas, while over 200 reform positions—nearly half of the total—sit empty seven months into the fiscal year. Mayor Brandon Johnson’s administration just patched together a budget tweak last week to refill 162 of those slots, scraping the funds from an expanded speed-camera network.
Progress? More like treading water in a storm.
What galls is how this “reform” has morphed into a reverse-discrimination machine. The AFL complaint zeroes in on recruitment pipelines that funnel applicants through race-tinted lenses, sidelining merit tests and fitness standards in favor of diversity quotas dressed up as fixes for “systemic inequities.”
Kass drove the point home: “Bureaucrats have embedded ‘equity’ principles throughout the Chicago government, including in the CPD, where race is a central consideration in recruitment, hiring, promotion, and retention decisions.”
It’s a direct challenge to Title VI and VII of the Civil Rights Act, which bar intentional race-based decisions in federally funded programs—and the CPD, as the nation’s second-largest municipal force, guzzles federal dollars like cheap gas.
This pushback arrives amid a broader on Chicago’s hiring habits. Back in May 2025, the DOJ launched its own probe after Johnson bragged from a church pulpit about stacking his administration with Black appointees by name, prompting accusations of overt racial favoritism. The EEOC jumped in too, sniffing around for Title VII violations. And don’t forget the February 2025 settlement where the DOJ nailed the CPD for national-origin discrimination against entry-level hires, forcing the city to rethink its five-year U.S. residency rule and cough up back pay. Layer on Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul’s ongoing role in the consent decree—he’s been in the saddle since 2019, defending it tooth and nail—and you get a picture of a state machine that’s all in on equity at any cost.
Critics see something darker here: a deliberate end-run around merit to engineer outcomes that fit a narrative, even as violent crime ticks up 15% year-over-year in Chicago through October 2025, per preliminary CPD stats. Why chase qualified candidates when you can chase checkboxes?
AFL’s Gene Hamilton put it bluntly: “Chicago is running an explicitly race-based government, and it’s using federal dollars to do it. No city is above the law.”
The group is calling on the DOJ’s Civil Rights Division to launch a full probe, potentially yanking funding and imposing fixes that actually prioritize competence over complexion.
Chicagoans deserve cops who earn their spots through grit and skill, not government-mandated lotteries. If this complaint sticks, it could force a reckoning—not just for the Windy City, but for every blue stronghold still clinging to DEI dogma in the face of plain-vanilla civil rights law. The streets won’t wait for the lawsuits to sort themselves out.
Source: https://patriot.tv/chicagos-police-hiring-turns-into-a-quagmire-with-equity-trumping-merit-and-law/
More Stories